2019
Marcellus Moore Purdue University
Jaylon Tillman Bowling Green University (Grand Valley State)
Jason Coulter Northern Michigan University
2020
Kanon Woodill Northern Illinois University
Adam Smith University of St. Francis (IN)
Jayln Givan University of Indianapolis (Michigan Tech University)
Jack Kiefer Augustana College
Carlos Conley Roosevelt University
Danny Nuccio North Central College
Josh Hlavacek Illinois Wesylan University
2021
Matt Bannister Benedictine University
Kaden McCombs St. Ambrose University
Justin Yeazell St. Xavier University
Colin Day Roosevelt University
Shane Wortman Carroll University
Grant Zak Augustana College
2022
Zach Michaels Augustana
Ethan Sam Minnesota-Duluth University
Gerald Floyd McKendree University
Tyler Tortorich Drake University
Demir Ashiru Ferris State University
Logan Rooney UW-Oshkosh
Shibu Mohammed UW-Whitewater
Sean Schlanser Augustana College
Austin McCombs St. Ambrose University
Jason O'Boye Wartburg College
2023
Eli Liapis University of Indianapolis
Nick Darwish Illinois College
Braxton Bartz Bryant University
Andre Deal Augustana College
Cam Morris Benedictine University
2024
Amiel Clark Roosevelt University
Dom Fasano Eastern Illinois
Malik Jassim Roosevelt University
Kevin Wilson Olivet Nazarene University